Comeback Players Award

[Fish Troll]

AL.

1. Cliff Lee (76)
2. Mike Mussina (28)
3. Milton Bradley (20)
4. Aubrey Huff (13)
5. B.J. Ryan (13)
6. Zack Grienke (12)
7. Francisco Liriano (8)
8. Justin Duchscherer (4)
9. Ervin Santana (4)
10. Rocco Baldelli (2)

NL.

1. Brad Lidge (53)
2. Kerry Wood (34)
3. Ryan Ludwick (27)
4. Jorge Cantu (23)
5. Fernando Tatis (18)
6. Jody Gerut (6)
6. Gabe Kapler (6)
7. Doug Davis (5)
8. Mike Lincoln (3)
9. Mike Hampton (2)
10. Chan Ho Park (1)

I don't like the idea of rewarding players for doing bad the year before.

[seaver41]

Why? Lee and Lidge deserve recognition for turning their careers around.

[Zack Attack Troll]

I would agree...

If the guy REALLY sucked and was sent to the minors or something, then that's fine with me if they win. But a simple down year...no way they should get it.

Lee was fine as a selection...i think Kapler should have won it for the NL. He was a friggin' minor league coach last year and to have the pretty good season that he did, well yea, I think he should have won.